Alter offers a useful local-first AI layer across Mac applications, but cloud routing, fair-use limits, permissions, local backups, and model quality need a deliberate test.
Direct verdict
Alter earns a shortlist for Mac power users who value local models and provider choice. Start with the free BYOK/local path, grant the narrowest permissions possible, back up local data, and buy managed access only after real tasks show a clear speed or quality gain.
What to verify
Use a non-sensitive workspace for ten days. Run 40 repeat tasks across selected text, document questions, meeting notes, and local versus cloud models. Measure accepted outputs, meaning-changing edits, latency, local resource use, provider calls, permission prompts, memory errors, backup and deletion behavior, and effective cost per accepted task.